D&D 5.5e’s first foray into universes beyond is a mostly well-designed book that’s let down by a few important elements.
D&D: World of Warcraft is the first of D&D 5.5e’s new universes beyond range. This is where Wizards of the Coast bring us conversions of 3rd party IP into D&D. We know that Star Wars will be getting a similar conversion next year and there are plans to combine with more IPs in the future.
The intention seems obvious; bring more players into the game by offering rules, options and guides to those settings. It’s also a chance to get existing players excited about their favourite IPs coming into their D&D games.
I think that means there’s possibly a lot riding on the success of this book. Some have been sceptical of how well D&D converts to different IP, what compromises have to be made and whether the game can stay true to the universe they cover. I think this is valid and based on this book, I think it’s they’ve gotten more right than wrong, but I still think there are some missteps.
For this review, I’ll be coming at it from the angle of a big Warcraft 2 and 3 fan, but as someone who has never played World of Warcraft (WoW) itself. Fortunately, there’s nothing in here that exclusively must be used only in Azeroth. In fact, I’m happy for my players to pull as much as they like from this book for their characters outside of Azeroth.
At a glance
Pros
- Mostly excellent subclass design
- Lots of new species, some with exciting new traits
- Spells are quite unique and loads of fun
- Monsters have interesting abilities and bosses have potential for epic encounters
- Absolutely packed with new character options
- Brilliant artwork
Cons
- Baffling design approach to the shaman
- A couple of subclasses fail to impress
- Human origin feats aren’t very good
- Adventures are minimalistic and lack detail
- Some unintuiative organisation
3.5/5 – D&D: World of Warcraft could be a really excellent book, and it has so many great qualities Unfortunately, it’s let down by trying to cram too much into too little space and by some strange design choices that feel at odds with the rest of the book.
A shaman without proper spellcasting is perhaps the most baffling design choice while the adventures just aren’t something you can run without adding lots of detail yourself. All of this is a shame because so much of what’s on offer oozes greatness.
What to expect from D&D: World of Warcraft
| Contents | D&D: World of Warcraft |
|---|---|
| Pages | 256 |
| Classes | 13 re-skins of existing classes |
| Subclasses | 9 |
| Species | 16 (11 new and 5 re-skins) |
| Specializations | 40 |
| Magic items | 25+ (including mounts) |
| Monsters | 50+ |
| Dungeon boss stat blocks | 30 |
| Spells | 60+ |
| Dungeons | 7 |
| Factions | 23 |
| Edition | 5.5e |
| Format | Digital and physical |
| Publisher | Wizards of the Coast |
If we’re talking about pure volume, D&D: WoW is absolutely packed with character options. 9 subclasses is the most of any 5.5e book so far, as is the 16 species and the massive number of spells.
All of this is necessitated by the fact that current character options don’t necessarily fulfil what players can build in WoW so more character options are needed to achieve this.
However, this isn’t everything! The book also contains:
- 7 eldritch invocations
- 2 wild shape forms
- 5 battle master maneuvers
- A new crafting system called professions
- A new reputation system called renown
- Lore for the various factions, species and regions of Azeroth
I think it’s fair to say that this is a pretty packed book. If nothing else, we can’t say WOTCs skimped on how much they’re giving us with a single release.
However, much of the book depends on the quality of what we get which is a little mixed.
How good is the content?
Class reskins are minimal effort

There are 13 class re-skins in here, but reskins is pretty accurate. It’s clear that creating 13 new classes would have been a massive effort on the part of the designers. It’s also obvious that not all WoW classes could shoehorn onto existing D&D classes. Instead, what we get are these reskins which I’m OK with in theory as a sort of compromise.
Essentially, most WoW classes simply map to an existing D&D class. A cleric becomes a priest, a fighter becomes a warrior and so on. Most of these then have specialisations which show you what subclasses, spells, feats etc to take to create a certain WoW build.
Some of these reskins don’t quite fit without a bit more work. For example, the death knight is mapped to the paladin, but then they use a combination of a subclass (the oath of the ebon blade) and some alternate class features to turn the paladin’s lay on hands into a death coil, their divine smite into a runic smite and so on. The demon hunter gets similar treatment using the ranger base class and the demon hunter subclass.
I think whatever they’ve done to manage this is low effort, but reasonable considering the scope and size of the task and I think all of this maps out OK.
However, there’s a glaring exception here and that’s the shaman. Shamans are totem wielding spellcasters, but have been replicated over from the barbarian class (you know, that class that’s famous for its spellcasting). Barbarians represent some of that tribalistic warrior vibe that shamans share which I guess makes some sense. They’re also given totems as an alternative (if a little disappointing in my opinion) feature.
They then attempt to address spellcasting through the subclasses with some paltry spells that they can’t even cast in combat still and some magical features. The subclasses themselves are pretty good barbarian subclasses, but just don’t work when trying to create a totem and spellcasting shaman. I think shaman players will feel especially hard done by here. Realistically, they needed a spellcasting barbarian or a more brawny druid, but they ended up doing neither.
I think many will complain about the class reskins. I think that may be a little unfair as creating 13 new classes from scratch was always going to be an overwhelming job. I think the compromise here is fine. I just wish they’d gotten the shaman right!
Subclasses try loads of new things with mixed results

The subclasses are mostly really well designed. Most of them are brand new too and they do a really good job of trying out new techniques and approaches for some really fun design.
Demon hunters, for example, get more powerful as they kill more, fuelling their abilities with death to become a ranger that can handle crowds. The warrior of mystic brews is a genuine defensive and offensive powerhouse with lots of flexibility through their brews and the discipline domain combines offence and defence really fluidly.
Sadly it’s not all brilliant. The shadow domain completely flops with difficult to use features that lack synergy with the base class and a completely underwhelming capstone feature. Likewise, the oath of the holy sacrifices too much from damage to try and make you a strong healer. Rather than marking this with offensive capabilities, it simply stops those capabilities which I think is down to flawed design.
It’s a shame those blemishes exist as 7 out of the 9 subclasses are genuinely great and I think you’ll get a lot out of them whether you’re playing in a WoW campaign or not.
Spells are refreshingly fun

There are over 60 new spells to try in D&D: WoW which is more than the magic-focused expansion Arcana Unleashed. It’s a lot and there was a danger that with so many new entries, that they might simply be stale imitations of existing spells.
Thankfully, that’s not really the case. In fact I’d say it’s the opposite. In trying to bring in magical capabilities from WoW, it feels like the shackles have been lifted a little and they’ve been given some new inspiration. There are loads of really fresh spell ideas that feel potent enough and well balanced. There’s a lot of spells I’d gladly take for my characters.
That’s not to say that all the spells are absolute bangers. They’re not. There are a few that deserve to be banished to the void. But dare I say it, I think this is perhaps the best expansion to spells I’ve seen in D&D!
Species are generally well designed with a couple of stand out options

There are 16 species, but a few of them (Human, Dwarf, Gnome, Orc and to some degree, Elf) are basically just the same species we have in the Player’s Handbook. That still leaves us with a lot of new species.
Most of these are a solid. Goblins are basically pretty much what we know from Monsters of the Multiverse, Forsaken have a lot of resilience and Haranir know a bunch of spells.
However, like with the subclasses and spells, there are some interesting design ideas that shine through on a lot of these species. Tauren are unarmed powerhouses with loads of ways to make strength unarmed builds great, Vulpera reduce the first damage they take in an encounter, Pandaren can use hit and run tactics and Earthen have a damage and heal breath weapon.
There are other unique traits at play here too which is really refreshing. I especially like the Tauren and Earthen species and think the Draenei are really good too.
The only issue is Worgen. It’s not necessarily a weak species, but basically all the traits are tied to being used proficiency bonus times per day. That means that for no good reason, their traits don’t work for some encounters on longer adventuring days, especially at low levels. There’s nothing mechanically overpowered that would suggest it should be so limited, but it is. Decent on short adventuring days, but bad on long ones.
Feats are either a bit rubbish or really good in niche ways

I was a bit underwhelmed by the Human origin feats and, like with a few things in the book, felt like they’d been handed to a junior designer without having their work checked. Most of the other feats are again, really unique and draw in some interesting mechanical ideas.
Hot streak uses burning in interesting ways, elusive brawler is great for defence and fists of fury has some serious damage momentum. Many of these feats are a bit niche and will only work well with the right build, but they open up new gameplay approaches which I think is worth applauding.
Absolutely stuffed with new character options
There are loads of fun little character options scattered throughout this book beyond the ones I’ve already covered that enhance gameplay in new ways. Whether that’s the druid’s new wildshape options, the warlock’s eldritch invocations, the battle master maneuvers, the mounts or the magic items, there are loads of these. In part, they’re here to flesh out the reality of playing a D&D game in WoW. Some of these are hit and miss, but largely, they add to your options, flavour and give great new tactics to use too.
Some will enjoy the new professions and renown systems

But they aren’t for me. I know many have asked for a bit more meat to crafting and it seems that professions go some way to handling this. I think the problem is anything more involved as a crafting system quickly gets clunky and complicated. For me, I just don’t like crafting mechanics whether that’s in video games or TTRPGs. I find them fiddly and like they stop me getting to the good stuff.
But many people do want a proper crafting system and I’m glad you can get it in this book. I have similar feelings about the renown system. For me, it’s just another thing to track. At least it’s simple, but it doesn’t feel important to my gameplay. I know some will be happy to build their renown with certain factions and have something tangible to show that growing, and for those people, I’m glad.
The adventures are completely barebones

Ahead of the release of D&D: WoW, I was excited to see that in amongst the many character options, would be 7 complete dungeons to throw my players into. This sounded great. Unfortunately, these dungeons are about as barebones as they come. I suspect they were working to tight page limits as the absolute minimum is placed into these dungeons (other than the monsters, but I’ll come onto that later).
Part of the problem is the designers give this sort of flexible approach to the setup so the dungeon itself needs to be flexible enough to accommodate several different missions. The problem is that everything about the dungeon then becomes a bit vanilla as a result. Some, like Onyxia’s Lair, are 2 pages where the map is simply a curving tunnel that leads to a cavernous lair. It didn’t really need a map.
If I’m being generous, the designers are trying to give us a blueprint to place our own adventures on. The problem with this is I want the adventures they’re creating to save me the time of doing that preparation. This is probably the section of the book that I’m most disappointed by.
Well designed monsters and epic boss battles
Some of the benefit of having a whole new universe to pull monsters from is that they have their own tricks you can transfer into D&D. It feels like that’s exactly what’s happened in the design process. Lots of monsters to flesh out your version of Azeroth with interesting new tricks.
For example, the felhound can sniff out the use of magic and has advantage on attack rolls against those that have cast spells. It can also stop grappled creatures from using the magic action. Dangerous for spell users.
This extends to bosses too who can transform mid-battle, gaining new powers like they might in WoW. For example, Illidan Stormrage can gain his demon form once bloodied and will get a bunch of new tricks to use at that point. This does make for some crunchy and lengthy battles, This could either make boss fights more epic or more laborious depending on how you feel about long encounters.
Art is great but some organisation principles make things hard to find

I’ve come to expect great art in WOTC releases nowadays and D&D: WoW is no different. The artwork oozes personality and importantly, combines typical D&D art style with WoW’s look and this is consistently great.
The design on the page is generally good and easy to read. However, I’m less of a fan of some of the organisation on display. They’ve approached character options by placing relevant options under the class or species you’re using so spells sit in the section for the class or species that spell is for. The same goes for feats too with one feat hidden in the professions section of the book. Equally, a couple of spells aren’t with their relevant classes but actually tucked away in the Elf section as Elves get these spells as standard.
I guess I understand this from a character creation perspective, but if I’m comparing what feats I want to take, it’s easier to do this from a single feats section rather than having to remember where the different feats were. The same goes for spells with some mages probably oblivious to the Elf spells that are also available to mages.
I also had an issue with the ordering of the adventures. They’re organised alphabetically, but it makes much more sense to me to have them organised by level. At least these are quibbles and preferences.
Who is this book for?
I think this is an important question. Is it for WoW fans, D&D fans or both?
I actually think this book is for DMs who are experienced in both D&D and WoW. I think this is because the lore isn’t that deep in the book. It’s more surface level, so if you want to run a WoW campaign, you’ll need some hefty context from the game. I think as well, if you want to run those adventures, you’ll really need a fair bit of experience as a DM to do so with such minimal support.
In contrast, I think for players, this book is for any player that either wants these character options or who has some interest in WoW, whether they’ve played the game or not. I think there’s everything here to enjoy jumping into the game with a DM guiding you through it. This includes players of any experience level, though I think the guided nature of character creation is intended more for WoW players unfamiliar with D&D, though the need for a separate Player’s Handbook makes the entry level a little trickier.
Verdict
D&D: WoW is an absolutely packed book! In fact, it’s so packed that I wish it was 2 books. One for lore, monsters and adventures and the other for everything a player needs. With more space and time, I feel like some of the tarnished elements of the book could have been overcome. Adventures could have been more meaty, the shaman could have been an actual spellcaster and the shadow domain and oath of the holy might not have sucked!
Thankfully, D&D: WoW is mostly an excellent book with some oddly glaring issues. Most of the subclasses are excellent, the same goes for the species and spells. Monsters and bosses are genuinely interesting and have the potential to be epic and there’s so much of this great content that it does make it easier to overlook the glaring issues with the book. But I can’t ignore them entirely. I still don’t have an excellent adventure I can run for my players in Azeroth and my players still can’t play a shaman that’s actually a shaman.
Sadly, this makes it hard to give the book a top score even though there’s a lot about it that I think is genuinely great. If all you’ve come looking for is an out of the box Azeroth adventure or to play a shaman, perhaps don’t bother with D&D: WoW. However, if you care about the other elements of the book, then you’re in for a treat… mostly.
3.5/5
